2451 Loma Linda St, Sarasota, FL 34239

Spacious Mid-Century Home in Sarasota: Your Opportunity in a Shifting Market!

Asking Price: $419,000

Discover this inviting 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom single-family home located at 2451 Loma Linda St, Sarasota, FL 34239. Built in 1957, this spacious 1,625 sqft residence offers comfortable living in one of Florida’s most desirable cities. With an estimated refinance payment of $2,947/mo, this property presents a compelling value in a market that is becoming more favorable for buyers.

Key Features:

• Generous Living Space: At 1,625 sqft with 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, this home provides ample space for a family, including a fireplace, central air conditioning, and a carport. It sits on a 7,988 sqft lot (approx. 0.18 acres).
• Established Construction: Built in 1957, this home features solid masonry and concrete foundation, typical of its era, offering a durable base for any desired updates. Records indicate a year updated of 1997, and appliances include a dishwasher, dryer, garbage disposal, microwave, range/oven, and washer.
• Sarasota Market Dynamics (34239 Zip Code):
  • Shifting to a Buyer’s Market: Sarasota as a whole, and specifically the 34239 zip code, is currently a Buyer’s Housing Market. This means prices tend to be lower, and homes stay on the market longer, giving buyers more negotiation power.
  • Price Trends: The median sold price in Sarasota was $496,832 in May 2025, down 4.9% from last year. For 3-bedroom homes in Sarasota, the median sold price decreased by 4.7% year-over-year to $509,700. In Sarasota County overall, 3-bedroom homes saw an 8.1% decrease in median price to $445,800. This property’s asking price of $419,000 is below the median for 3-bedroom homes in both the zip code and the county, positioning it as a potentially strong value.
  • Negotiation Friendly: A significant 79% of homes in Sarasota sold below asking price last month, and 95.23% in 34239 sold below asking price on average in May 2025, indicating that buyers have a good chance to negotiate.
  • Days on Market: Homes in 34239 had a median of 90 days on the market in May 2025, which is up from last year, providing buyers with more time for due diligence.
• Desirable Location in Sarasota: This home is situated in a well-regarded area of Sarasota, offering convenient access to:
  • Beaches & Outdoors: Just a short drive to world-renowned beaches like Siesta Key and Lido Key, as well as numerous parks and outdoor recreational opportunities. Arlington Park, with its pond, nature walk, playground, and aquatic complex, is within walking distance.
  • Downtown Sarasota: Close proximity to downtown Sarasota, featuring vibrant arts and culture, including the Sarasota Opera House, Marie Selby Botanical Gardens, and various galleries and performing arts venues. The Ringling Museum is a major cultural attraction.
  • Shopping & Dining: Enjoy diverse shopping and dining experiences, from upscale boutiques on St. Armand’s Circle to local eateries in Southside Village.
  • Sarasota Memorial Hospital: The home is conveniently located close to Sarasota Memorial Hospital.
• Schools: The property is assigned to Sarasota County Public Schools. Nearby assigned schools include:
  • Alta Vista Elementary School (PK-5, 5/10 GreatSchools Rating, 0.2 mi away)
  • Brookside Middle School (6-8, 6/10 GreatSchools Rating, 1.5 mi away, and an International Baccalaureate World School)
  • Sarasota High School (9-12, 4/10 GreatSchools Rating, 0.4 mi away, known for its strong academic programs including AP courses and arts programs)
  • Note: Sarasota also boasts highly-rated public schools like Southside Elementary (10/10) and Ashton Elementary (10/10), and top-ranked private schools, offering diverse educational choices.
• No HOA Fees: This property does not appear to have HOA fees, which can result in significant savings on monthly expenses.
• Property History: While specific sale history for this exact address is limited in recent public records, other properties on Loma Linda St have estimated values ranging from the high $200s to over $700k depending on size and condition, indicating varied property values in the area. The general market trend in Sarasota has shown significant long-term appreciation.

Important Considerations:

• Potential for Updates: As a home built in 1957, while well-maintained, it may offer opportunities for buyers to update interior finishes and personalize the space to modern tastes.
• School Ratings: While Sarasota offers excellent schools, some of the directly assigned public schools have moderate GreatSchools ratings. Buyers prioritizing top-tier public schools may wish to investigate school choice options or private alternatives.
• Walkability/Bikeability: While some amenities are nearby, the Walk Score is 28/100 (Car-Dependent) and Bike Score is 44/100 (Somewhat Bikeable), suggesting a car is generally needed for errands.

This home at 2451 Loma Linda St offers a fantastic blend of space, location, and value in a desirable Sarasota neighborhood. With the current buyer’s market conditions, it presents a compelling opportunity to own a piece of this beautiful Florida city.

Priced at $419,000 – don’t miss the chance to make this your new Sarasota home! Schedule your private showing today.