2380 Bay St, Sarasota, FL 34237

Prime Sarasota Gem with Endless Potential for $394,900!

Discover an incredible opportunity at 2380 Bay St, a spacious 3-bedroom, 3-bathroom single-family home perfectly situated in the highly sought-after Poms Park 3 subdivision in vibrant Sarasota, FL. Built in 1963, this expansive residence offers 2,672 sqft of living space on a generous 0.38-acre lot, providing immense potential for those seeking to create their dream home in a prime location.

Step inside and envision the possibilities! This large home features a fireplace, central heating and cooling, and a layout ready for your personal touch. While some public records indicate 2 beds/1 bath and 1,641 sqft, the listing provides 3 beds/3 baths and 2,672 sqft, suggesting significant expansions or renovations have taken place, offering substantial living space (buyers should verify all property details). The property also includes a spa, a concrete foundation, stucco exterior, and an attached garage.

Experience the Sarasota Lifestyle: Sarasota consistently ranks as one of the best places to live in the U.S., offering a unique blend of cultural sophistication, stunning natural beauty, and a relaxed coastal atmosphere.

• World-Class Beaches: Just minutes away from some of America’s best beaches, including the renowned Siesta Key Beach with its sugar-white sand. Lido Beach and Longboat Key are also easily accessible.
• Vibrant Arts & Culture: Sarasota is a hub for arts and culture, boasting The Ringling Museum of Art, Ca’ d’Zan (the Ringling’s former mansion), the Sarasota Opera, ballet companies, numerous art galleries, and a thriving performing arts scene.
• Outdoor Paradise: Enjoy year-round outdoor activities with an average of 248 sunny days. Explore Myakka River State Park for hiking, biking, kayaking, and airboat tours, or visit the Marie Selby Botanical Gardens for tropical beauty.
• Dining & Shopping: From the upscale boutiques and diverse restaurants of St. Armands Circle to the charming downtown area with its unique shops and cafes, Sarasota offers an array of dining and retail experiences.
• Growing Economy: With a healthy labor market and an unemployment rate lower than the national average, Sarasota offers job opportunities, particularly in healthcare and tourism.
• Excellent Schools: The city is home to high-quality primary and secondary education options.

While Sarasota offers a fantastic lifestyle, it’s worth noting that housing costs are generally higher than the national average, and traffic can be congested, especially during peak tourist season. However, this property at $394,900 with an estimated refinance payment of approximately $3,394/mo, presents an appealing entry point for a home of this size in Sarasota. The Sarasota housing market has seen home prices up 15.3% year-over-year in June 2025 (median sale price of $617K for all home types), indicating a strong market with appreciation potential, though median days on market have increased to 88 days.

Don’t miss this exceptional chance to secure a substantial home with significant potential in one of Florida’s most desirable cities. Schedule your private showing today and envision your life in beautiful Sarasota!